How to Nurture Your Online Audience

Jordan Crump • October 9, 2022

You have heard from every social media expert about how to grow your audience, but we never seem to talk about to nurture your audience. If you're not nurturing your audience and serving them, then your social media really isn't doing what it's supposed to do. So, today I wanted to give you three tips on how to nurture your online audience in a way only you can.

Every social media manager talks about how to grow your online audience, but we never seem to talk about how to nurture your online audience. I don't care how many people you have following you,  if you're not nurturing them and serving them, then your social media really isn't doing what it's supposed to do. So, today I wanted to give you three tips on how to  nurture your online audience in a way only you can.


Share your expertise


One of the things that's always on my checklist for a client’s post is “How is this post showing their expertise?” I believe that every post should show your knowledge, your authority and your expertise in a subject that only you know.  There is so much information out there and you're not the only person talking about your industry. But there is a way that you can show your individual expertise from your own experience, your own education (formal or not), or your own perspective.  Every piece of content should be showing your expertise in some way. 


No, this doesn't mean just educating things that are 100% Googleable. This means educating about topics that people want to hear about, but from your unique perspective. For example, I recently posted about brand storytelling.


Brand storytelling is a hot topic right now. A lot of people are interested in learning. Even though I was sharing a lot of information that other experts are also talking about, I added a slide specifically about how to showcase your brand values and tie that into your brand storytelling. That is a special piece of my expertise that I take a lot of pride in, and I also attract a lot of people that values matter a lot to them. That slide was easily the most shared and most saved part of that post. And it shows how important it is to share your own expertise so whatever you're trying to talk about isn't just lost to the noise of the Internet.


This is also a great time to remember a really important part about creating social media content: and that is to not be like everybody else. It sounds easy or simple, but every time that I go through my Reels, they all look the same because everyone's trying to copy each other. And, we're not about that here. We're about showing your expertise as you are individually and uniquely. 


Find ways to showcase your knowledge and your authority in what you really want to be an expert in. It could come from your education, your experience, or just your unique perspective on an important topic. Doing this helps your audience connect with you, look to you as an expert on the subject, and also make you someone that they want to come to over and over again for wisdom and advice on things that matter to them. And being in that place – a place where people trust you and look to you for expertise – is an amazing place to be if you're looking to sell a service or get them to trust you with a certain product.


 Share social proof


 I can't begin to tell you how important it is that you are showing social proof. Whether that comes in the form of reviews, testimonials, photos of DM’s or emails. Whatever it is. Sharing social proof is important to show that you are making an impact, people are loving what you're doing, and the biggest reason is – nobody's going to share it but you. Nobody's going to share all the great reviews you're getting or all the great feedback other than you. So it's super important as you look to nurture an audience to keep showing social proof. How others are enjoying what you're doing, learning from what you're doing and really getting a lot of good out of following and working with you.


Social proof is also sharing about your expertise and about yourself. Again, nobody's going to share your knowledge but you. So, create content that genuinely proves your knowledge and truly teaches your audience. This is one of the easiest ways to really nurture your audience Is to truly educate them.


Remember what social media first started and everything was about entertaining, educating or inspiring? The days before we even had content pillars. Well, I kind of want you to go back to that. And when I say education, I don't mean just educate like everyone else. Like I said, social media is not a place for everyone to act and talk the exact same way – even though people act like that's how it's supposed to be. Don't just copy and paste what other people do. Find a way that you like to educate and you like to share your expertise in a real and authentic way. People will respond to that and that will nurture your audience into the kinds of people that you want them to be. People that look to you for what you know and bring to the table. 


Share your real life


I remember when social media was just starting out and everybody felt so pressured to share everything about everything. People were sharing their latest salad, their baby’s third smile today, and anything that they could possibly think that needed to be shared with the world. Now, I don't want you to exactly be like that. But, I want you to find real and intentional ways you can show your everyday life to people.


People have all kinds of different reactions to being asked to share more of themselves on the Internet. For some people, this is super natural and they're really comfortable sitting in front of the camera, talking to an audience, and just sharing about their everyday life. But, for a lot of us, we kind of fall in the middle. We have things you want to be private about and we have things that we're comfortable sharing about. 


So, when I'm telling you to share more about your real-life, I also want you to think about what you want to keep private versus what you want to share with the world. For example, I don't feel comfortable sharing my son's face on my business Instagram. So I don't. 


However, I have gotten so much good out of sharing about my hot girl walk everyday. It's something that I knew I was going to repeat, that was already a part of my daily routine, and it helps people form a community around something that has nothing to do with my normal job. But even though my hot girl walk doesn't have anything to do with social media, it still helps people connect with me (which is what nurturing you audience is really all about.) 


One of my clients shares about her dog, and it's been fun to see where people connect with and talk about that. Another one of my clients loves gardening, so she shares her garden and updates about how her garden’s doing. And people connect with that too!


You need to harness your superpower. And what's your biggest superpower? Yourself.


What's unique about you, what you're passionate about, what you love talking about, and what's everyday for you that maybe isn't everyday for everybody else. Think about the things that happen everyday that you would love to share about. They can be the meals that you cook, your family life, a hobby or a passion of yours, or even just the daily shenanigans of your pet. Whatever it is, find something that you can share about from your everyday real life that people can connect with and form a community around. People really love the raw and real from your life, so be intentional about how you give them that. 


I hope these three tips help you form a strategy that's unique to you to nurture your audience. Growing our audience is only so powerful if we're not actively trying to nurture them. Find fun and real ways to show off your knowledge, share that social proof, and create content from your everyday life that people can connect with. With these three elements, you’re going to get started on a great nurture strategy, and of course- if you ever want a girl on that, I’m right here for you!


Don't want this to end? Let's work together HERE.

Listen to the The Space Social Podcast episode this blog was based from here.



By Jordan Crump January 13, 2025
In today's rapidly evolving sales landscape, the art of soft selling has undergone a dramatic transformation. Gone are the days of pushy tactics and aggressive pitches. Instead, we're witnessing a renaissance in relationship-based selling that leverages technology while maintaining genuine human connection. Here are the nine key trends that are reshaping soft selling in 2025.
By Jordan Crump January 8, 2025
You might not tell anyone you're working with a social media strategist... but there will be signs. While your competition is still trying to figure out their next post, you're already three steps ahead. Here's what happens when you invest in strategy:
By Jordan Crump March 11, 2024
We’re excited to introduce you to the always interesting and insightful Jordan Crump. We hope you’ll enjoy our conversation with Jordan below.
By Jordan Crump March 4, 2024
Every scroll, like, and view can signify interest, Instagram stories emerge as a potent tool for identifying and nurturing warm leads. Those who consistently engage with your stories aren't just passive observers; they're potential clients intrigued by what you have to offer. Embracing specific strategies for your Instagram stories can significantly alter your engagement rates and conversion paths.
By Jordan Crump February 7, 2024
Welcome to the digital landscape, where email isn't just a means of communication but a cornerstone of your brand's online presence. As we navigate the complexities of the internet, one aspect stands out as crucial for any email marketer: Email Authentication. This technical necessity is key to ensuring your messages land where they're supposed to - in your audience's inboxes. In this blog, we'll delve into why email authentication is essential, especially in light of recent changes by major email providers. Whether you're an experienced marketer or just starting, understanding and implementing this feature is vital for the effectiveness of your email campaigns. Let’s get into the details and ensure your emails get the visibility they deserve.
By Jordan Crump June 16, 2023
I had a high risk pregnancy. I couldn't keep any food or water down, I had insomnia, and I had gestational hypertension and diabetes. All of these things made those 9 months really hell for me, and while I am so grateful for my son, it was such a hard experience for my body and for my mind. And, with all of these conditions, stress was just not helpful.
Jordan sitting on a blue couch working on her laptop
By Madison Goade April 7, 2023
It’s time you become a HUGE fan of an email list- and let me tell you why! First, email is such an intimate place to really connect with your audience. It’s one of the best places to nurture warm leads and make lasting relationships with clients who really want to work with you. Plus, it’s a powerhouse place to write content you can use over and over again- in captions, blog posts, reels ideas, and make your content all super streamlined + super connected. It’s also an amazing way to connect directly with your audience. No algorithms or hopes that they see it- just you and their inbox. A quality email list is SO powerful as you’re running your business. They give you an inner circle when you’re launching something new or running a sale or even for market research.
By Jordan Crump March 20, 2023
Today we are talking about all things influencer marketing! I am joined by one of my business besties Jaiden Robinson, who is also a social media manager but specializes more with influencer marketing. I wanted to dive into this topic more with Jaiden as I know influencer marketing is a real hot topic right now and a lot of businesses are curious what's the best way in, what's the best way to go about it, and how influencer marketing can work for them. So, I asked Jaiden some questions that I hope help you figure out if influencer marketing is the best move for you!
Jordan in pink shirt in pink room wearing jeans
By Madison Goade March 16, 2023
For this podcast I’m joined with my fave copywriter, Maddy Aucoin to talk about AI and how it’s impacting our businesses and marketing strategies. Maddy’s big focus is human-first, ethical copywriting that genuinely connects with you and feels human. We’re both diving into AI today- what it means for you, your business, your marketing, and your service provider needs.
woman in pink shirt
By Jordan Crump March 6, 2023
In marketing we overcomplicate things way too much and it just isn’t necessary. Just being intentional and doing simple tricks can get you so far! Here’s 5 things I did to get more inquiries in 2023.
More Posts
Share by: